- Neighbourhood
- Lower East Side
- Style
- Speakeasy
- Known for
- No sign and no cocktail menu - bartenders build drinks to your taste on the spot · Occupies the former Milk & Honey space that started the modern speakeasy template · Expanded into the adjoining former Good Guy's space in late 2025
- Prices
- $$$$ · cocktails $21+
- Getting in
- Book ahead. Book on Resy
- Food
- Drinks only
- Hours
- Daily roughly 5pm-3am per third-party listings; confirm current hours
- Recognition
- Past No. 1, World's 50 Best Bars (Best Bar in North America, 2017); repeat World's 50 Best Bars honoree
- Address
- 134 Eldridge Street, New York, NY 10002
Checked: Checked Nov 2026: Wikipedia and trade coverage confirm Attaboy expanded into the adjacent Good Guy's space in November 2025, evidence of continued, growing operation; the bar's FAQ/Resy booking page remains active. No closure reports found.
Photo: Attaboy, from their website.
Part of these nights
What people say
No menu, no sign, just your taste
Attaboy occupies the old Milk & Honey space on the Lower East Side, a narrow, dim room with no sign and no printed menu, where you tell the bartender what you like and they build from there. The format rewards being specific about spirit and flavor; whiskey, Manhattan-style, or fruit-forward requests all come back tailored and sharp. There's no food here, so it works best as a stop before or after dinner rather than the whole night's plan. Knock, wait for a nod at the door, and expect the room to feel more like someone's living room than a bar.
What people love
- cocktails built entirely around your own taste
- bartenders with deep, easy knowledge of spirits
- relaxed, intimate speakeasy atmosphere
Worth knowing
- seats are limited, standing room is common
- arrive early evening or on a weeknight for a shorter wait
- vodka isn't part of the pour, worth knowing if that's your drink
Our own summary of public Google reviews, in our words. Nothing here is a quote.
Same neighbourhood