Buying for someone who makes a good Old Fashioned? Skip the novelty mugs. Here is what we keep on our own bar, and what we would be happy to unwrap.
Everything below is a tool, a book or ice. Each one comes with a drink to make with it, so the gift gets used the same night.
We pick these ourselves. As an Amazon Associate, Barback earns from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.
Stocking stuffers
Under $25
Small, useful and used every week.
-
01
Under $25 · A Bar Above
A Bar Above Premium Japanese Jigger, Double-Sided Stainless Steel
Measuring is the whole difference between a home drink and a bar drink. The extra lines inside mean no more guessing at three-quarters of an ounce.
Make with it: Daiquiri, Margarita
See it on Amazon -
02
Under $25 · Barfly
Barfly Deluxe Antique Hawthorne Spring Strainer, Gold
Keeps ice chips and lemon pulp out of the glass. The gold one looks good enough to leave out on the bar cart.
Make with it: Whiskey Sour, Clover Club
See it on Amazon -
03
Under $25 · Tovolo
Tovolo King Cube 2" Ice Tray with Lid, Charcoal
Two-inch cubes melt slowly, so the last sip of an Old Fashioned tastes like the first. The lid stops them tasting like the freezer.
Make with it: Old Fashioned, Negroni
See it on Amazon -
04
Under $25 · Tovolo
Tovolo King Craft Ice Mold (single 2-inch cube)
One big cube, one small price. The easy stocking stuffer for someone who has never tried proper ice.
Make with it: Old Fashioned
See it on Amazon
The real upgrades
Under $50
The tools that make a home drink taste like a bar drink.
-
05
Under $50 · Cocktail Kingdom
Cocktail Kingdom Koriko Weighted Shaking Tin Set (Stainless Steel)
The same weighted two-tin shaker you see behind nearly every craft bar. It seals tight, cracks open easily and never leaks.
Make with it: Daiquiri, Whiskey Sour, Margarita
See it on Amazon -
06
Under $50 · Mixology & Craft
Mixology & Craft Mixing Glass Set (24 oz glass, jigger, spoon, strainer)
Martinis and Manhattans get stirred, not shaken. A heavy 24 oz glass with the spoon and strainer to match keeps them silky and cold.
Make with it: Manhattan, Dry Martini, Negroni
See it on Amazon -
07
Under $50 · W. W. Norton
Liquid Intelligence: The Art and Science of the Perfect Cocktail
For the friend who already owns every recipe book. It explains why ice, acid and bubbles behave the way they do, and it will change how they make drinks.
Make with it: Gin Fizz
See it on Amazon -
08
Under $50 · Ten Speed Press
Death & Co: Modern Classic Cocktails
The book working bartenders still hand to new hires. It teaches you how to build a drink, not just copy one.
Make with it: Naked and Famous, Penicillin
See it on Amazon -
09
Under $50 · Union Square & Co.
The PDT Cocktail Book: The Complete Bartender's Guide from the Celebrated Speakeasy
Over 300 recipes from the New York bar that made the hidden phone-booth door famous. A great first serious cocktail book.
Make with it: Paper Plane, Oaxaca Old Fashioned
See it on Amazon -
10
Under $50 · Ten Speed Press
Smuggler's Cove: Exotic Cocktails, Rum, and the Cult of Tiki
The best book on rum and tiki, written by the people behind one of the best tiki bars in America. Get it for anyone who orders a Mai Tai.
Make with it: Mai Tai, Zombie, Jungle Bird
See it on Amazon -
11
Under $50 · Strongwater
Strongwater Cocktail Bitters Sampler Set, 4 Flavors
Four small-batch bitters that change a familiar drink overnight. A dash of something new in an Old Fashioned is the cheapest upgrade there is.
Make with it: Old Fashioned, Manhattan
See it on Amazon -
12
Under $50 · Fee Brothers
Fee Brothers Bar Cocktail Bitters Set of 6
Six classic flavours, from orange to black walnut, from a Rochester family firm that has made bitters for decades. Covers most of the classics in one box.
Make with it: Sazerac, Martinez
See it on Amazon -
13
Under $50 · Mixology & Craft
Mixology & Craft Bartender Kit, 13-Piece with Bar Stand & Boston Shaker
Everything to start a home bar from zero: a proper two-tin shaker, jigger, strainers, spoon and a stand to keep it tidy.
Make with it: Daiquiri, Old Fashioned
See it on Amazon -
14
Under $50 · Various (USA Oak Smoker)
Cocktail Smoker Kit with Torch & Wood Chips (Premium Set)
A bit of theatre that actually changes the drink. Smoke over an Old Fashioned or a Negroni is the trick guests ask about.
Make with it: Old Fashioned, Boulevardier
See it on Amazon
For the obsessed
Under $100 and the splurge
Clear ice is the thing serious home bartenders end up chasing. These make it easy.
-
15
Under $100 · Wintersmiths
Wintersmiths Ice Baller Double – Crystal-Clear Ice Ball Mold
Makes two crystal-clear ice spheres in a normal freezer. The bubble-free kind you get at a hotel bar, not the cloudy ones from a silicone tray.
Make with it: Old Fashioned, Oaxaca Old Fashioned
See it on Amazon -
16
The splurge · Wintersmiths
Wintersmiths Phantom Mini Clear Ice Maker
For the person who has made clear ice their hobby. It turns out several clear cubes or spheres at once.
Make with it: Negroni, Old Fashioned
See it on Amazon
Good to know
Questions
What is a good gift for someone who likes cocktails?
A weighted two-tin shaker, a Japanese jigger and a two-inch ice tray. All three cost under $50 together and fix the most common home-bar problems: leaks, guesswork and watery drinks.
What do you get a home bartender who has everything?
Clear ice or a book that explains the why. A Wintersmiths clear-ice mold or Dave Arnold's Liquid Intelligence both land with people who already own the basics.
What is a good cocktail gift under $25?
A Japanese jigger, a Hawthorne strainer, or a two-inch King Cube ice tray. Each gets used every time they make a drink.
Can you buy alcohol as a gift on Amazon?
Not in most of the US. That is why this list is tools, ice and books. Pair any of them with a bottle from a local shop.
Barback: 100 Cocktails
Every recipe on this site, built into an app for your bar cart. Use it free on your phone. Open the app.
Picked by Barback, last checked November 9, 2026. Prices and stock change on Amazon.