Nolita · Wine & cocktails

La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels

It's a genuine escape from cocktail-forward LES/Nolita nightlife into something quieter and more wine-focused, without feeling like a tourist trap.

Date nightQuiet conversationBefore dinner
Neighbourhood
Nolita
Style
Wine & cocktails
Known for
450+ bottle wine list, heavily French, from the original Paris wine bar's NYC outpost · Candlelit, below-grade back room built for long, quiet nights · Named among the city's best wine bars by VinePair and Star Wine List in 2026
Prices
$$$ · cocktails ~$17–21
Getting in
Book ahead
Food
Snacks and small plates
Hours
Evenings; weekend reservations suggested; confirm current hours
Recognition
Named among VinePair's Best NYC Wine Bars (2026); featured on Star Wine List
Address
249 Centre Street, New York, NY 10012

WebsiteMap

Checked: Checked Nov 2026: 2026-dated listings (VinePair 'Best NYC Wine Bar' mention, Star Wine List feature) reference the Centre Street location as currently operating. No closure reports found.

Photo: La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels, from their website.

What people say

Candlelit French wine, expert guidance

4.6 out of 5 on Google, from 600 ratings. Checked November 2026.

Below street level in Nolita, this room channels its Paris original with exposed brick, low light, and a wine list that runs deep into French regions most bars skip. The staff lean into walking you through bottles and glasses rather than just pouring them, and the small snack menu of cheese, charcuterie, and a few hot bites is built to pair rather than fill you up. It works best as a slow-down spot, for a date, a catch-up, or a happy hour that stretches long. Reservations help on weekends since the room is small and fills quickly.

What people love

  • Staff take real time to walk you through wine choices
  • Cheese plates and small bites pair well with the wine
  • Intimate, cozy room that feels transported from Paris

Worth knowing

  • Reservations are worth making on weekends since seating is limited
  • International wine options are thinner than the French list

Our own summary of public Google reviews, in our words. Nothing here is a quote.