East Village · Tiki

Otto's Shrunken Head

It's the rare tiki bar with zero pretension - cheap drinks, a dive-bar crowd, and tropical cocktails that are better than the room has any right to serve.

GroupsLate nightDancingGoing solo
Neighbourhood
East Village
Style
Tiki
Known for
Open since 2002 - one of Manhattan's oldest running tiki bars · Live bands, DJs and an in-house photo booth most nights · Loaded tiki cocktails served in genuine dive-bar surroundings
Prices
$ · cocktails under $14
Getting in
Walk-ins only
Food
Drinks only
Hours
Open into late night daily; confirm current hours
Address
538 East 14th Street, New York, NY 10009

WebsiteMap

Checked: Checked Nov 2026: Songkick's venue page lists upcoming 2026 shows booked at this address, confirming current operation; this 2002-opened bar has no closure reports found.

Photo: Otto's Shrunken Head, from their website.

What people say

Dive-bar tiki with live music

4.5 out of 5 on Google, from 927 ratings. Checked November 2026.

Otto's looks like a tiki bar but drinks like a dive, with pufferfish lamps and bamboo paneling over a jukebox running punk and rock instead of ukulele music. The tiki cocktails are strong and served in mugs worth collecting, while bands, DJs, and a photo booth keep the back room busy most nights. It's cramped and unpolished in a way regulars treat as part of the charm. Go for a loud, cheap, slightly chaotic night rather than a polished cocktail experience.

What people love

  • Strong, elaborate tiki cocktails served in collectible mugs
  • Live punk and rockabilly bands most nights
  • Welcoming to birthdays and private parties in the back room

Worth knowing

  • Space is tight, so expect a cramped, dive-bar feel
  • Some regulars note drink prices have crept up

Our own summary of public Google reviews, in our words. Nothing here is a quote.

Same neighbourhood

Also in East Village