Tribeca · Speakeasy

Smith & Mills

It's the quintessential hidden-in-plain-sight Tribeca bar: no sign, a door that looks closed, and a tiny carriage-house room that's been a neighborhood fixture on every 'best Tribeca bars' list for over a decade.

Date nightQuiet conversationNightcap
Neighbourhood
Tribeca
Style
Speakeasy
Known for
Unmarked garage-door entrance in a 19th-century carriage house · Candlelit room with communal, church-pew-style seating · Classic cocktails paired with a tight, well-executed small-plates menu
Prices
$$$ · cocktails ~$17–21
Getting in
Walk-ins only. Only
Food
Snacks and small plates
Hours
Sun-Mon 4pm-11pm, Tue-Sat 4pm-1am per the bar's own site (confirm current hours before going)
Address
71 N Moore St, New York, NY 10013

WebsiteInstagramMap

Checked: Checked the bar's own site (current hours posted, active reservation link, no closure notice) plus Infatuation and Tribeca Citizen coverage and a 2024 piece confirming the owners are still actively expanding (a Rockefeller Center location). A direct 'Smith & Mills closed' search turned up nothing relevant. Checked Nov 2026.

Photo: Smith & Mills, from their website.

Part of these nights

Financial District, after dark

What people say

Tiny candlelit carriage house with top cocktails

4.4 out of 5 on Google, from 74 ratings. Checked November 2026.

Smith & Mills hides behind what looks like a closed garage door on a quiet Tribeca corner, inside a carriage house that's over a century old. The room is small, just a handful of tables and a single bar, lit by candles and a hanging schoolhouse lamp that makes it feel more like a found secret than a bar. Martinis and other classic cocktails are the draw, paired with a short food menu built around a single hot plate behind the bar. It suits a date or a last stop after a bigger night out, somewhere to settle in and let the room do the work. Even longtime regulars describe it as a small, enduring favorite in a neighborhood full of flashier options.

What people love

  • The intimate, converted carriage-house room feels unlike anywhere else nearby
  • Classic cocktails like the martini draw praise, alongside mussels and a burger
  • Bartenders are described as kind, knowledgeable, and happy to make off-menu drinks

Worth knowing

  • Kitchen service can run slow on busy nights, so order food early
  • It's a small room that fills up fast, so expect to stand or wait

Our own summary of public Google reviews, in our words. Nothing here is a quote.