- 45 ml1.5 ozblended scotch
- 20 ml0.75 ozlemon juice
- 20 ml0.75 ozhoney-ginger syrup
- 7.5 ml0.25 ozIslay scotch
Garnish: candied ginger
- Method
- Shaken
- Strength
- ~20% ABV
- Difficulty
- ●●●
Method
- Shake the blended scotch, lemon juice and honey-ginger syrup hard with ice.
- Strain into a rocks glass over fresh ice.
- Float the smoky Islay scotch gently on top.
- Garnish with candied ginger.
The story
A New York bartender in the mid-2000s built this as a wink toward old folk-remedy cocktails, naming it for the medicine while actually loading it with honey, ginger and smoky scotch instead. It is one of the most imitated modern cocktails of its decade.
Where the Penicillin comes from
Australian bartender Sam Ross built the Penicillin at Milk & Honey in New York in 2005, naming it for the medicine as a joke while actually loading it with honey, ginger and smoke instead. It spread from that one bar onto menus everywhere and is now one of the most copied cocktails of the modern cocktail revival.
Why the ratio works
Think of it as two parts blended scotch, three-quarters lemon and three-quarters honey-ginger syrup, with a quarter-part Islay float on top. The honey-ginger syrup has to be assertive enough to stand up to peat smoke, so it leans sweeter and spicier than a plain sour syrup. The lemon keeps all that sweetness from turning syrupy, and the Islay float sits on top rather than mixed in, so the first sip is smoky and each one after that is a little less so.
No Islay scotch? Swaps that work
Any peated single malt works as the float, not just Laphroaig or Lagavulin, so reach for whatever smoky Islay (or Islay-style) bottle you can get. Out of peated scotch entirely, a small float of smoky mezcal gives a different but related edge, swapping peat smoke for agave smoke. For the base, any blended scotch works fine; a softer blend keeps the drink from getting too smoky before the float even goes on.
Shaken, and why a rocks glass
It's shaken because it has citrus in it: a hard shake chills, dilutes and gives the honey-ginger syrup and lemon a silky texture. It's strained over fresh ice into a rocks glass rather than served up, because the smoky float and the spice from the ginger hold up better slightly diluted and cold than ice-cold and small, the way a citrus drink in a coupe would be.
Flavour
Variations
- Mezcal Penicillin — swap the Islay float for a smoky mezcal; the smoke comes from agave instead of peat, and the honey-ginger syrup reads a little more tropical against it.
- Bourbon Penicillin — swap the blended scotch base for bourbon and keep the Islay float; sweeter and rounder up front, with the same smoky finish on top.
If you like this
Try these next
Quick answers
Penicillin questions
How do you make a Penicillin?
Shake the blended scotch, lemon juice and honey-ginger syrup hard with ice. Strain into a rocks glass over fresh ice. Float the smoky Islay scotch gently on top. Garnish with candied ginger. You need 45 ml (1.5 oz) blended scotch, 20 ml (0.75 oz) lemon juice, 20 ml (0.75 oz) honey-ginger syrup and 7.5 ml (0.25 oz) Islay scotch.
What's in a Penicillin?
Blended scotch, lemon juice, honey-ginger syrup and Islay scotch, garnished with candied ginger.
Is a Penicillin shaken or stirred?
Shaken. Shaking chills, dilutes and aerates the citrus or cream.
What glass is a Penicillin served in?
A rocks, over ice cubes.
How strong is a Penicillin?
About 20% ABV once it is diluted, about as strong as a glass of fortified wine.
What is a Penicillin cocktail?
A Penicillin cocktail is a modern whiskey sour built on blended scotch, lemon juice and a honey-ginger syrup, shaken and strained over ice with a float of smoky Islay scotch on top. It was invented at Milk & Honey in New York in 2005.
What does a Penicillin drink taste like?
Spicy ginger and honey against tart lemon and scotch, with a smoky, peaty note from the Islay float that gets stronger the further down the glass you drink.
Can I make a Penicillin without a peated Islay scotch?
You can skip the float and use a little extra blended scotch instead, but you'll lose the smoky top note that gives the drink its name-making character. A smoky mezcal float is the closest substitute if you have no Islay scotch at all.
Barback: 100 Cocktails
Every recipe on this site, built into an app for your bar cart. Use it free on your phone. Open the app.